OSC Answers Questions
QUESTION:
I just finished reading Stone Tables and could not help but notice
that the relationships between Moses, Miriam and Aaron somewhat resembled
those of Ender, Peter and Valentine. (Youngest brother given preferential
treatment in the world, Older brother jealous, Older sister caring and
understanding.) Knowing that some of the research you conducted for Stone
Tables preceded that of Ender's Game, is it possible that the relationships for the
siblings in Stone Tables was the precursor for the relationships of the siblings in
Ender's Game?
-- Submitted by Patrick Poyfair
OSC REPLIES: - January 6, 2000
What an interesting parallel. There are differences, though -- for
instance, Miriam could also be bitchy and judgmental, and I don't think
Valentine does much of that in Ender's Game, and Peter was cruel and
mean-spirited, while Aaron was merely fanatical in pursuit of his ambition to
achieve a lofty goal. In a sense, the only real parallel is simply: Third child with
an older brother and sister. That's the family Exodus gives us for Moses, but
when I was novelizing Ender's Game (the short story has no family in it), I had
no conscious thought of the Stone Tables character roster -- I simply drew on
my own family as I saw it when I was seven or eight. Because, like Moses, I am
also a third child with an older brother and sister. My older brother is not nasty
like Peter, and my older sister is not perfect like Valentine -- but when I was
seven I thought they were! So in giving Ender a family I lazily based his family
situation on mine-as-a-child, and then exaggerated and extrapolated from there.
In no sense is the fictional representation of Peter or Valentine meant to
represent my real siblings -- I simply used my family as the starting point because
... well, why not?
That doesn't mean that I didn't also draw on some of the thinking I did in
writing Stone Tables, since I created the play back in 1972 and didn't write the
novel of Ender's Game until 1984. But if there was influence there, I had no
conscious knowledge of it.
Previous
Next
|