posted
I suspect that I know who will answer this question....
I need a fast-acting (close to instant) ingested poison available in Europe or Australia in the mid-1880's. Failing that I have to have a protracted dinner scene or invent some rare thing from the Outback.
I've been researching till my eyes cross, and I know that some of our members are a vast treasure house of trivia.
posted
The two fastest acting poisons in the world:
1. Curare- a preparation made from the toxic skin of the Poison Dart Frogs by natives of America. It's preparation was observed by Sir Walter Raleigh and several others around 1807 and earlier. The problem is, it doesn't work ingested, though it takes only a small amount. I'd say that a small amount applied to a small barb/hook hidden in food would work adequately to inject the poison. Physical effects would be immediate, but actual death wouldn't take place for about 9 minutes. (death by asphixiation)
2. Tobacco (nicotine) Tabacco leaves can be soaked in the sun for several days, then the concoction is allowed to evaporate, leaving a thick black tar. The tar tastes VERY strong, but it only takes a small amount, preferably in coffee (to cover up the taste). The victim would become very hot, very stimulated, pass out very quickly, and die (most likely of heart failure) in as little as 1 minute. I say that its a little slower than curare because a person with a strong constitution might actually take 10 or 15 minutes to be "legally dead". A frail old woman or child would take only moments.
As with any poison, the amount ingested would largely affect how quickly the poison set in. Either of THESE poisons would DEBILITATE almost instantly, but wouldn't kill for several minutes. They were known, but rarely used (or hard to obtain, in the case of curare).
posted
A little side note on the particular deaths.
Curare- The victim would die of asphixiation, completely conscious until the end, with there heart continuing to beat for a short time after they were dead.
Tobacco- The victim would die of heart failure, but would fall unconscious in a swoon nearly instantly, and breakout in a hot sweat.
posted
Sea snake Venom? I don't know if it would work by ingesting or not. They are much more poisonous than land snakes. Of course your character would have to catch one and milk it, or get it to bite the victim. But they are prevalent in Austalia. It can take as little as 5 minutes for it to take effect. In the timeframe that you are talking about, there would be no anti-toxin. It is still tricky today to heal someone who has been bitten.
Posts: 471 | Registered: Sep 2003
|
posted
These are both very good. (don't I wish Iochaine powder were a viable solution...) The method of delivery is a glass of champagne. The glass itself is the vehicle for the poison. Honest, it really needs to be that way. I can make one up if I have to, but I am hoping that there is an existing poison that would work.
The story that this goes with is in Fragments and Feeback now, if you're curious.
posted
Austrailia has the highest population of deadly poisonus spiders. You might be able to use that. (Also the spleen of a polar bear has a fatal does of Vitamin-A in it. Not helpful but good to know.)
Posts: 1895 | Registered: Mar 2004
|
posted
Cyanide would be my bet as well. You ingest it. Death by asphyxiation, if I remember correctly. Face turning blue, lips purple, eyes revulsing, etc. Pretty fast acting. The effects are almost immediate, and death occurs within minutes. And it does have a smell of bitter almonds(it is, however, tasteless, and you wouldn't feel it in a glass of champagne). Also, it was a favourite of victorian authors (including Conan Doyle), so it would fit your story. And, incidentally, Socrates committed suicide with hemlock, which is not fast acting - it paralyses the muscles starting from the extremities towards the heart, and it's a painful and slow death (death by asphyxiation as well, I reckon - when your lungs stop working).
[This message has been edited by Silver6 (edited July 17, 2004).]
posted
Oh my, Pyre Dynasty, I'm almost afraid to ask HOW you know about the fatal dose of Vitamin A in polar bear spleens... but I am curious what research led you to that!
I don't know too much about this, but maybe:
hemlock belladonna/deadly nightshade oleander
Not sure about preparation or timing, and suspect that you have already checked but thought I'd throw them in. I'm sure what you decide to use can be intensified (extra-strength) through preparation to make it fast-acting.
Not sure if they did champagne and kir in those days, but that might be a way to disguise a poison - a berry-based poison.
when I searched on "poison ingest victorian" just for fun. Oh yeah, what about arsenic? Any way to make a small dose fatal, other than just turning you pale?
Sounds like you'll enjoy writing this!
Lee
[This message has been edited by punahougirl84 (edited July 17, 2004).]
Atropine Found in the belladonna plant. Very poisonous, though not as much so as aconite. Can be absorbed through the skin as well as ingested. Symptoms: Dry mouth and tongue. Difficultly swallowing. Flushed skin leading to rash on upper body. Headache leading to giddiness, hallucination, delirium. Breathing and pulse fast. Dilation of pupils is most distinctive feature - eyes look almost black. Later, signs of paralysis, then coma and death.
Cocaine Not often used in murder. An overdose overstimulates the eart fatally.
Colchicine Pale yellow crystals from meadow saffron. Kills in small doses. Fatal within 7 to 36 hours. Death is by paralysis of repiratory system.
Coniine Oily liquid from hemlock. Not painful to die from it, but progressively paralyses the body until in the end heart or lungs fail. No post-mortem signs except of asphyxia.
Gelsemium Seldom used. Symptoms are muscular weakness with slow pulse, dilated pupils. Death from respiratory failure.
Nicotine Liquid at room temperature (the only alkaloid, along with coniine, which has this property). Yellowish oil, discolouring to dark brown in light. Poisoning usually done with insecticide, as this is where nicotine is used (only a tiny amount in cigarettes) Absorbed in skin or drunk. Symptoms: Burning sensation in mouth. Vomiting and diarrhoea. Mental confusion and dizziness. Convulsions then death vy paralysis of respiratory system. Death is within minutes - only cyanide is quicker.
Opium and Morphine Raw opium very seldom used as a poison as acts slowly and has a strong smell. Morphine is a white crystalline substance extracted from opium. Used as analgesic, but overdose can be fatal. Fatal dose varies but usually about 5 grams. Symptoms start within minutes. Drowsiness. Nausea. Face swollen and coloured. Patient feels cold. Cyanosis (greyness of extremities) Eyes dilate to pinpoints that don't react to light and dark (this is the most distinctive symptom). Breathing slow and noisy. Pulse slow and weak. Death is by respiratory failure.
Physostigmine Used by some tribes as an "ordeal" poison. Causes excitement and hallucination. Overdose causes vomiting. Severe overdose interferes with heart and causes death.
Scopolamine (Hyposcine) Naturally occurring in several plants including belladonna and henbane. Can be administered internally as well as externally. Tiny amounts can be used to treat anxiety or motion sickness. Larger doses break down ability to make reasoned judgements, so has been used as a "Truth Drug" Even larger doses cause hallucinations and floating sensation. Death is when the heart is affected.
Strychnine Derived from a berry. Colourless solution with a very bitter taste, noticeable even in very weak solutions. Very powerful. 100 milligrams is always fatal, though much smaller doses have killed within 20 minutes. Symptoms: Symptoms come on within 2 or 3 hours - sometimes much faster - but them proceed rapidly. Restlessless. Feeling of suffocation. Face muscles contract and victim looks as if they're grinning. This is followed by very violent and distorting contractions, followed by a period of rest, then an attack of even more violent contractions. Patient is conscious but in agony, unable to speak because of lockjaw. Pulse is incredibly high. Death is during a convulsion, from paralysis of respiratory system. Sometimes confused with tetanus or epilepsy (though different from epilepsy as person is conscious throughout.)
Cantharidin Spanish fly. When crushed and rubbed on skin, causes blisters. Taken orally, a small dose results in kidney damage. Larger doses inflame mouth, throat and stomach. Vomit and urine contain blood. Headache, delirium, convulsions, leading to death.
posted
Dang, you guys know some great ways to kill somebody. Should I worry? Polar bear foi gras anyone? (okay, that's the liver, but who cooks with the spleen)
Thanks for the link punahougirl, good stuff there. Angel Flower is particuarly appealing because of the irony of the name.
Arsenic is what's in the story right now, but it wasn't fast-acting enough for the scene I had in mind. The symptoms of Strychnine are tempting because I like the idea of them grinning at the head table, dying in front of everyone. If I can figure out a way to mask the bitter taste...
posted
Maybe you don't need to hide the bitter taste. A champagne toast and a particularly lethal dose would work. A large amount of tobacco poison touching the tongue for only a brief instant would cause poisoning. And the effects would be instantaneous (not the death necessarily, but the effects).
Even if the character spit it out, it'd work. Or if they just grimaced from the taste of bad champagne. . . .
posted
Did they know about fugu in the 1880s? (Japanese roulette--eat an improperly prepared fugu (blowfish) and die very quickly.)
I don't know if this would help, but from what I understand about it, champagne would be suitable as a trigger: nitrobenzene is a poison that used to be found in shoe polish the fumes of which could enter the skin and cause death, especially if the victim had alcohol in his/her system.
There's a story about a young man going to someone to buy a love potion that would make the young lady fall passionately and desperately in love with him. The vender kept asking him if he would also be interested in an indetectable poison, but the young man insisted he was just interested in making this girl absolutely obsessed with him and him alone.
So the vender sold him the love potion, all the while describing the virtues of his indetectable poison, even though the young man was not at all interested. When the young man left the shop, the vender told him, "See you later."
There was an expedition (to find the North Pole, if I remember correctly) in which every man died because they were stranded, had used up their supplies, and tried to survive on the polar bear(s) they killed.
The high vitamin A levels in polar bear livers killed them off.
posted
I vote for cyanide. Interestingly, it kills by cellular asphyxiation. So it's not like suffocation, which has to be maintained until all the oxygen in the blood stream has been used up. Even though there's plenty of oxygen in the bloodstream, it can't get into the cells. Death occurs in seconds.
Posts: 932 | Registered: Jul 2001
|
posted
Fugu was definitely enjoyed in the 1800's, and well before, at least in Japan. A character that had visited Japan could easily have known about Fugu.
Here's a quote from one website (http://www.destroy-all-monsters.com/fugu.shtml):
quote: During the Meiji period, fugu was prohibited in many areas of Japan. The Tokugawa shogunate completely banned blowfish consumption, but by the mid-1800's it had returned as the government's power over the people waned.
posted
Look into foxglove--the origin of digitalis. Considering how fast digitalis acts in heart patients, I wonder if a fatal dose would give you the fast-acting effect you want. And foxglove is a plant that would probably have been cultivated in Australia by that time in history. I don't know much more about it--tastelessness, flavors, etc. But it is considered one of the more deadly therapeutic herbs. Holy irony!
Also, concerning poisonous critters in Australia, Australia is home to eight of the ten deadliest snakes in the world.
posted
It really has been fun researching this topic, morbid though that sounds! Here's another neat site for future reference, for writing only, of course!!
posted
Somewhat off topic, but at least tenuously related, is another interesting website to squirrel away. This came from a reading of Mary Robinette's story, and running across the word "mulignane", with which I was unfamiliar. An internet search yielded a veritable treasure trove for future writing reference, this site:
posted
I can't believe I'm hooked on researching poisons... Anyway, this guy's site goes into interesting details of poisons and he does it in a narrative form.
>>I need a fast-acting (close to instant) ingested poison available in Europe or Australia in the mid-1880's. Failing that I have to have a protracted dinner scene or invent some rare thing from the Outback.<<
Does it have to be the poison that does the killing? Why not a poison that immediately causes hallucinations that result in the character doing something spectacularly stupid and deadly? (such as eating a polar bear pancreas, or gizzard or whatever that body part was) Such as trying to demonstrate that facial rouge protects against gunshots?
posted
As far as I know, atropine is only fatal if mixed with something, for example opium. It is virtually undetectable in this sense and was a popular assasination tool in the middle ages. It is also makes you hallucinate if you smoke it (no I have not tried, but you can and belladonna isn't illegal, so...BUT you DIDN'T hear this from me). Atropine is actually used in patients after they have had heart surgery. And belladonna extracts (ie. atropine) really calm the stomach if someone can't stop vomiting.
posted
ha-HA! I've got it! It's perfect. I just rewrote my poison scene and I love my poison of choice.
Want to know?
Glass blowers use arsenic to create an opalescent sheen in glass. If you combine arsenic with any number of things, some of which are found in champagne, you get arsine gas. And alcohol can leach the arsenic from the glass. Even a tiny dose is fatal.
Everything's fatal in large amounts. But I can't find an LD50 for potassium listed in any of my usual sources, so I don't know exactly how much you'd need to take before it was poisonous. I'd expect that more than about 10 grams at a time would be risky.
posted
If the character REALLY liked salt, and if they each had individual salt cellars at their plates, then you could replace regular salt (sodium chloride) with Sylvite (potassium chloride) extracted and concentrated from sea salt. That would fit the level of technology, no?
Potassium chloride (KCl) is a metal halide which is used in medicine, scientific applications, food processing and in judicial execution through lethal injection
It occurs naturally as the mineral sylvite and in combination with sodium chloride as sylvinite.
Orally it is toxic, but the LD50 is around 2500 mg/kg. Intravenously this is reduced to just over 100 mg/kg but of more concern are its severe effects on cardiac muscles; high doses can cause cardiac arrest and rapid death.
[This message has been edited by mikemunsil (edited July 21, 2004).]
[This message has been edited by mikemunsil (edited July 21, 2004).]
posted
That's a good question, Mr. Fisher. Arsine gas is fatal in tiny amounts but not in the amounts that would dissipate away from a champagne flute. Wine glasses and flutes, are designed to concentrate the aromas, which is why.... crap. Which is why the old flat champagne glass went out of style. Shoot. They wouldn't be using flutes.
There are disadvantages to having a husband in the wine industry. This is a piece of fashion inforation that I would be just as happy not knowing right now.
Cyanogen is a very deadly poison, a grain of its potassium salt touched to the tongue being sufficient to cause instant death," The New York Times reported on Feb. 8, 1910. If Earth were to pass through Halley's tail, an astronomer predicted, "the cyanogen gas would impregnate the atmosphere and possibly snuff out all life on the planet.
posted
The coral snake, although extremely venemous, must chew to inject enough venom to kill, which takes a while. They aren't easily milked for their venom either. And, no, I never tried, but I knew someone who did that kind of thing for a living.
Posts: 2710 | Registered: Jul 2004
|
posted
I vote cyanide. Tasteless, odorless, readily available (comparably speaking), and unusually fast acting. There are very few poisons that work in just a few minutes. People usually don't want someone to die from poisoning while they are still around, wouldn't it just be easier to shoot them? Your chances of getting away are about as good. I'm gonna go find that death scene in the fragments page.
posted
Cyanogen is simply a gas derived from cyanide (or the chemical radical shared by all cyanides).
Cyanide isn't tasteless or odorless (though a significant fraction of the population can't smell the gas), but it is a pretty darn good poison.
And a good point on slow acting poisons. It really would be a lot better to kill somebody with a slow poison than a fast one. Many substances fit this bill, too.
posted
This is probably far more than you ever wanted to know, but I guess I should post it anyway...
There is a poisonous Australian frog, commonly called the Southern Corroboree Frog (its scientific designation is Pseudophryne corroboree), that manufactures its own alkaloid toxin by eating specific insects and secretes said substance from glands in the skin. This particular class of alkaloid has been labeled ‘pseudophrynamine’ after the frog’s genus. The pseudophrynamines were recently found to be efficient blockers of nicotinic receptors (biological components involved in neurological function). This and similar toxins are some of the most powerful cardiotoxins known to man. The venom is neurotoxic as well as myotoxic, and is curare-like in effect, causing irreversible blockage of neuromuscular signal transmission.
Alkaloids, complex organic compounds of nitrogen, have many forms, including strychnine, morphine, quinine, cocaine, and nicotine. Apparently, many alkaloids also come from plants.
This excerpt from the Australian Department of the Environment and Heritage details the frog’s habitat (which might come in handy if you need to write a scene where the toxin is ‘harvested’):
quote:The nationally endangered Southern Corroboree Frog has an extremely limited distribution, restricted to sub-alpine areas in the Australian Capital Territory and Kosciuszko National Park in the south of New South Wales. The species is only found at high altitudes within an area of about 400 square kilometres. The Southern Corroboree Frog uses two distinct types of habitat during its lifecycle: pools, wet tussock grass and wet heath for breeding; and forest, sub-alpine woodland and tall heath next to the breeding areas during other times of the year.
Females only breed once a year, and the tadpoles are slow growing, spending over six months in shallow pools. Its restricted habitat and specialised breeding pattern makes this species extremely vulnerable to disturbance.
Bear in mind that this is current habitat information. I’m not sure how much (if any) change has occurred since the late 19th century. I would hazard a guess that this particular type of frog was far more plentiful in the 1880s...before modern pollution and encroachment of habitat (as well as other currently unknown causes) pointed this species toward the trail of critical endangerment, where it finds itself today.
Another viable (and more clinically specific) alternative to using frog venom would be this:
The Blue-Ringed Octopus is another one of the smaller, but more deadly marine animals that inhabit the coastal waters around Australia. The blue-ringed octopus is normally light in color, with dark brown bands over its eight arms and body, with blue circles superimposed on these dark brown bands. When the octopus is disturbed or taken out of the water, the colors darken and the rings turn a brilliant electric-blue color, and it is this color change that gives the animal its name. The blue-ringed octopus secretes a very deadly poison, either by biting with its parrot-like beak, or by squirting the poison into the water surrounding it.
The direct bite from the blue-ringed octopus is usually painless, but the deadly effects of the poison will be noticed immediately. The poison apparently interferes with the body's nervous system. The victim will immediately experience numbness of the mouth and tongue, blurring of vision, loss of touch, difficulty with speech and swallowing, and paralysis of the legs and nausea. If the victim does not receive medical treatment immediately, full paralysis may occur within minutes, followed by unconsciousness and death due to heart failure and lack of oxygen. There is no antivenom for the poison from a blue-ringed octopus. It is usually necessary to perform continuous CPR on a victim until the effects of the venom have subsided. This may take several hours, but it may mean the difference between life or death for the victim.
Hope some of this helps (if you don’t go cross-eyed reading it all!)
Inkwell ------------------ "The difference between a writer and someone who says they want to write is merely the width of a postage stamp." -Anonymous
posted
This was the thread that really made me join Hatrack, and since there are a few new people around, I thought they might enjoy it.
Also, check this out:
quote:Suicide tree' toxin is 'perfect' murder weapon
15:56 26 November 04
Exclusive from New Scientist Print Edition. Subscribe and get 4 free issues.
A plant dubbed the suicide tree kills many more people in Indian communities than was previously thought. The warning comes from forensic toxicologists in India and France who have conducted a review of deaths caused by plant-derived poisons.
Cerbera odollam, which grows across India and south-east Asia, is used by more people to commit suicide than any other plant, the toxicologists say. But they also warn that doctors, pathologists and coroners are failing to detect how often it is used to murder people.
A team led by Yvan Gaillard of the Laboratory of Analytical Toxicology in La Voulte-sur-Rhône, France, documented more than 500 cases of fatal Cerbera poisoning between 1989 and 1999 in the south-west Indian state of Kerala alone. Half of Kerala’s plant poisoning deaths, and one in 10 of all fatal poisonings, are put down to Cerbera.
But the true number of deaths due to Cerbera poisoning in Kerala could be twice that, the team estimates, as poisonings are difficult to identify by conventional means.
Unnoticed homicides
Using high-performance liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry to examine autopsy tissues for traces of the plant, the team uncovered a number of homicides that would otherwise have gone unnoticed. This also suggests that some cases put down to suicide may actually have been murders, they say.
Although the kernels of the tree have a bitter taste, this can be disguised if they are crushed and mixed with spicy food. They contain a potent heart toxin called cerberin, similar in structure to digoxin, found in the foxglove.
Digoxin kills by blocking calcium ion channels in heart muscles, which disrupts the heartbeat. But while foxglove poisoning is well known to western toxicologists, Gaillard says pathologists would not be able to identify Cerbera poisoning unless there is evidence the victim had eaten the plant. “It is the perfect murder,” he says.
Three-quarters of Cerbera victims are women. The team says that this may mean the plant is being used to kill young wives who do not meet the exacting standards of some Indian families. It is also likely that many cases of homicide using the plant go unnoticed in countries where it does not grow naturally.
Journal reference: Journal of Ethnopharmacology (vol 95, p 123)