I'm very pleased to see this start up again.

A special Thank You to Mike for the shove, to Kathleen for the Challenge thread and the trigger, to everyone who's excited about it. I hope it gets you writing (and finishing) a fantastic story.

Here's a link to the rules for the Resurrected Rewrite Challenge #1:
http://www.hatrack.com/forums/writers/forum/Forum7/HTML/000001.html

And, for those who STILL haven't caught on, a link to the discussion that got it all going:
http://www.hatrack.com/forums/writers/forum/Forum1/HTML/003802.html

Keep your hands and arms inside the ride at all times, and HAVE FUN!!!

[This message has been edited by djvdakota (edited March 01, 2007).]
 

J
InarticulateBabbler
Pyre Dynasty
trailmix
Dee_Boncci
hoptoad
RMatthewWare
Dude
quantumphotonkid
Zoot
Dulci
francli
and...ME!

If you still want to jump in, feel free!
 

So, I read the story today. You know. The Little Tailor.

A word of caution as you approach your challenge:

The version of the Little Tailor in the Challenge post is not a simple little tale from which to build a nice 5000 word story. It's considerably more complex than that. In reality, it's four stories in one with a common theme ("Seven with one blow!") running throughout.

Speaking from past experience, simplify.

Identify those four stories and choose only one or two from which to gain your inspiration. Otherwise you'll be trying to wrestle a dragon into a shoebox.

Do NOT feel the need to rewrite the entire story. Do NOT feel the need to be religiously true to every plot point contained within it. Pick and choose the parts that get your brain churning and discard the rest.

Let your imagination and interests steer for you.

In the first rewrite challenge (the goat one) we had such a sweeping range of stories, it amazed even us. We had a tap-dancing ninja mom, a space-pirate, a bragging spider (published, by the way), Big Bob--Used Car King, Loki the trickster, a deliciously dark tale of a magical town called 'Bridgetown,'a faithful Samurai warrior, an Australian Outback seer, a time-traveling scientist, and a couple of very clever but true-to-the-original rewrites.

 

How're things coming?
 

It is four stories but there is a single overriding theme.
Should we discuss those themes here or keep them to ourselves?
I have decided on setting and created a scene list and am working to maintain the theme AND have content recognisably derived from the original.

[This message has been edited by hoptoad (edited March 05, 2007).]
 

So, hoptoad, theme away.
 

It would be fun to recast the entire tale, but doing it in 5000 words is well above my present ability.

So even if it's a resounding dud in the context of the challenge, I think it will be a neat little story.
 

That's the real purpose of it.

Matt
 

As for the recurring theme, I had a different take on it. The obvious "Seven with One Blow" statement wasn't the theme to me, on first read. It was Victory-by-Wit! When the "Seven with One Blow" theme was introduced, I immediately thought of it as a "Braggart Winning the Day" theme, and I didn't really like that.

Then I started thinking about Indiana Jones. He was an accidental hero. Twisting my first train-of-thought with the accidental hero line of reasoning, I came up with a "Accidental Hero lucking his way to a Kingdom" theme.

LOL - I have since murdered that idea, though. I'll save what I came up with for the posting.

[This message has been edited by InarticulateBabbler (edited March 07, 2007).]
 

There's a link in the first post of the thread. It's tough to read because it isn't punctuated well. If you google "the little tailor" you can find better punctuated versions. It's an old Brother's Grimm fairy tale, so it's pretty easy to find.
 

You are all welcome to find other versions and refer to them if you prefer.
 

The little tailor creates for himself a 'heroic' past and others 'buy in' to the story.
Why does he do it?
Why did he not clarify the point?
We are never sure whether he believes he is a hero or whether he is mendacious.
When his 'cover' seems to be blown, he creates an even bigger story.

Is it a coping mechanism?

This is just one theme.
There are plenty of other ie:

Rulers only hold the power if the people let them.
We make our own luck.
The precarious position of a leader who gains his position through deceit, division and creating fear.

Another question: would you want a wife like that? Why does he want to hold on to her? What happens when she loses fear of him?

 

Conceited, an inflated sense of self-worth, deceitful. I really wanted him to lose in the end, so...

quote:

---

Rulers only hold the power if the people let them.
We make our own luck.
The precarious position of a leader who gains his position through deceit, division and creating fear.

---

• When his 'cover' seems to be blown, he creates an even bigger story.
  

I didn't get him creating a bigger story, he just implied it. He let everyone believe what they wanted to--he didn't actually claim anything until the very end. I found that he overcame each challenge by using his wits, and technically did defeat what he claimed to defeat.

quote:

---

Another question: would you want a wife like that? Why does he want to hold on to her? What happens when she loses fear of him?

---

I wouldn't want a wife like her anyway--she is clearly materialistic and condescending, and she comes from liar's stock. She plot's murder with her father over the fact that he's a tailor and not some professional warrior. He never claimed to be.

[This message has been edited by InarticulateBabbler (edited March 08, 2007).]
 

I think I work with that guy.
 

quote:

---

I didn't get him creating a bigger story, he just implied it.

---

Won't deny the cleverness of the little tailor.
I did not say he lied.
I said he deceived.
He certainly loves the "deception" more than the truth and will allow others to keep believing it while ever it serves his purpose.

Whether it was intentional or not is not clear -- initally.
It is clear toward the end, however, that he will try to hold on to power through continued deception and causing fear and probably division.

Will he divide the woman and her father in order to defeat them?
Has the lying old king finally run into a better liar?

What happens when a child of the union discovers the truth too?

I also forgot to mention the theme of dishonestly profiting off the honest efforts of others. Remember the giant and the tree?

[This message has been edited by hoptoad (edited March 08, 2007).]
 

I really don't discount all of the opinions that I have read here, I can see how you got to them, but I have a completely different point of view.

hoptoad, I think we have managed to start something. I bet some creative juices are flowing now. If everyone has taken a stake in whether or not they like the tailor, I think we've made him real.

I would imagine some are going to assassinate our tailor; turn him into a bad guy, or make him a truly "good" guy--in their opinion. Either way, it's beginning to affect people.

[This message has been edited by InarticulateBabbler (edited March 09, 2007).]
 

10,000 word stories have a very limited number of markets (I'm learning from experience). 5000 word stories have a very broad range of potential markets.

If your story is getting too big, examine your characters. Can you cut anyone? Examine your conflicts. Are there any the story doesn't need? Are you trying to use too much of the source material?

To shorten a story you just have to start shaking off the fluff. That's HARD sometimes. It's almost like cutting off your dog's legs because you often have an emotional attachment to the words that have come from yourself. But if you do it, you just might find that your dog is happier without them.

Sick imagery there, I know.

You only 'win' the challenge if you finish it.
 

I have a lot of doubts about this story as it stands now (I can't come up with much of a motive for the antagonist(s)), but I'll have a week or so to revise it, then maybe I'll toss it out on the F/F for Shorts forum to try and get a little feedback before the end of the month.

Dakota: thanks for the suggestions on revising. I think I will be coming in under 8k with the draft, so with a bit of ruthlessness I can probably get it in the ballpark of 5k.
 

It's still in 1st draft, because of time constraints. I am going to be away from the 29th or 30th until April 2nd. If I am going to send it out, it's got to be soon.
 

ANNOUNCEMENT:

I will be out of town from the 31st to the 2nd of April. You guys are one your own to finish up the challenge and share the stories around.

Whew!
 

It would have been awesome.