This is topic Who Do You Write Like? in forum Books, Films, Food and Culture at Hatrack River Forum.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.hatrack.com/ubb/main/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=2;t=057307

Posted by advice for robots (Member # 2544) on :
 
So far, the majority of the samples I've fed into the analyzer have me writing like James Joyce. But there's a smattering of James Fennimore Cooper, Vladimir Nabakov, Raymond Chandler, and, yes, Dan Brown.

Who do you write like? http://iwl.me/
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
http://whatawonderful.tumblr.com/post/820508648/i-write-like-science

also of interest:

http://shakespearessister.blogspot.com/2010/07/i-write-white.html
 
Posted by rollainm (Member # 8318) on :
 
I've gotten both David Foster Wallace and Stephen King with multiple writing samples. Dan Brown once.
 
Posted by scifibum (Member # 7625) on :
 
Chuck Palahniuk, Cory Doctorow, Ursula LeGuin, Stephen King, Edgar Allen Poe.

I don't think I have much confidence in this algorithm. Those were all forum posts. My style doesn't vary that much.
 
Posted by advice for robots (Member # 2544) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Samprimary:
http://whatawonderful.tumblr.com/post/820508648/i-write-like-science

also of interest:

http://shakespearessister.blogspot.com/2010/07/i-write-white.html

I wonder if the thing would indeed get more accurate with a larger list of authors. Right now it's fun but pretty much useless.
 
Posted by Cor (Member # 4295) on :
 
Someone I know tested out a theory. Seems if you type in "magic" over and over, you get Rowling, and if you type "horror" or something like that, you get King.

It's a fun gimmick, but I also heard that it's being funded or at least used as a promotion for a self-publisher of questionable reputation.
 
Posted by PSI Teleport (Member # 5545) on :
 
More importantly, it's not accurate unless you put in some crappy writing and get "The kid that sat next to me in kindergarten and ate the paste."
 
Posted by advice for robots (Member # 2544) on :
 
Not "accurate," then. "Representative"? [Smile]

I wonder why this thing went viral. NPR even did a piece on it.
 
Posted by Baron Samedi (Member # 9175) on :
 
I did "robot robot robot robot..." and got Isaac Asimov. I did the first few stanzas of The Jabberwocky and got Lewis Carroll. So I guess that's OK.

I then gave the program a few brief, profane suggestions for what it could go do with itself, and it told me I wrote like Jonathan Swift. I guess all these years I was missing the point of Gulliver's Travels.
 
Posted by Baron Samedi (Member # 9175) on :
 
I put a few of Sarah Palin's tweets in there, and it says she writes like William Shakespeare. So I guess we all owe someone an apology. [Big Grin]

(Actually, I copied and pasted Moroni Chapter 10, and it came back as Shakespeare. But it's surely all the "cometh" and "denieth" and such.)
 
Posted by Nighthawk (Member # 4176) on :
 
I write like Cory Doctorow.

...

Wait... What?
 
Posted by Baron Samedi (Member # 9175) on :
 
I thought I'd try for Steven King, so I entered the following text:

quote:
blood guts artery spurt blood murder kill death tear out disembowel dismember cut into pieces slash with a knife and spray with blood.
It gave me Margaret Atwood. So much for that.
 
Posted by rivka (Member # 4859) on :
 
King is slightly more subtle.
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by advice for robots:
I wonder if the thing would indeed get more accurate with a larger list of authors. Right now it's fun but pretty much useless.

It says I write like Cthulu. I don't know what that means ... AAAHHHH
 
Posted by Samprimary (Member # 8561) on :
 
IA IA I̺̳͙̲̜̩̩̝̜̱̞̠̹̣̘͖͗̍͑͆̌̐̕ͅÄ̶̧͕͚̻U 2;̤͇̣ͣͬ͆̽ͯ̑ͥ͐͋̎͆̉ͭͥ̋͆̀̀ ̙͓̞̪̫̪̥̰̟̲͖̌̂ͩͯͦ̿̎̓̎̊̊ͣ̃̐̚͢͞Ị̶ ;̬̝̺̫͖̻̠̼̥ͩ̋̓͛̋͂ͩ̃́̏̀ͅẮ͐̄̐͒̓͋ͥV 9;̑͊͟҉̻̟̞̗̦̙͓͕̗̘̗̤͢ͅ ̸͈̲̼̙̹͇̗͎͉̻̱̰͔̥̏ͭ̄͌ͬ̿͒ͪ̓̈́̓͜͟C̸ ;ͨ́͊̄͑̄̊҉̛̘̫̟̝̤͚̱͖̝͈̦̗̮͎͔̱̦͇̀T̸ 01;̟̣̱̰ͭ̓̔͌̄ͥ͛̅͐̈́̏̿͢͡͠H̸̛̱̞̳̬̜̹̗&# 854;͎͙̮̤̞̮̞̳̟̪̘ͮͬ̽̈́ͮͯͧ̓͛̒̐̽ͧ̈̿́͌&# 780;Ủ͔̝̺͔͖͇͉̱̦̱͎̱̠͍̱̯͚̖͙̽̏̔̆̂͐̓ͨͫ& #781;̃͋̚͠͠L̸̺̼̠̣͂̂̓ͨ͗ͤ͋̅ͨͩ̎ͯ̀U̠͇̺͚͕̻ ;͍̫̠͉̪̟͈̥̗̻̫̓̀ͮͤ̎̇̎̉ͩ͗ͨͨ̎̎́͢ͅͅ ̡̡̒̍̏̓̋̎̍̿ͦ̌͗̐͐̈̚͏̮͈̩̦͇̞̟͉͍̮̠͍ ̲̳͓̝̪ͅF̶̲̼͇͉̱̙͕ͥ̊̃̄͂͑ͥ͛̚͢͝T̷͕̼͚U 2;̯̟̭͓̞̬̦̘̦̪̥̰̟̼̓̍ͩ̐́̂̆ͭ͑ͨͩ͑͆̃́U 6;͜H̵̝̪̘͎̜̠̩̱͓͇̮̠̑͗ͣ̏̍ͨ͛̈́ͮ̀̚͢Ả͓&# 826;͉̗͔̮̱̦ͣ̔́̚̚͜G̸̢̖̜̳͕̹̝̞̟͇̗̞̪̩̟͈& #790;̙ͦ̌ͩ̍̎̔ͭͫ̏̒̍̄́ͅ'̵̧̡̲̳̺͔̲̞̻͎̱̱̟ ͖͓̞̦̮̻͚̊͐ͦ̓̓̑ͥ͡N̵̢̤͖̲̮͈̜̝̥̣ͫ̈́͒ ;̐ͦ͗́͊͆́̎̉̈́́͢͟ ̧̯̳̺̻̾͊ͥ̈́ͦ̐͑̈́́͠A̴̛͙̫͖̭̳̞̦̬͉̙̲ ;͖̣̤̳͊̓̂̉̀̕L̫̩͖̗̹̝̤͎̭̥̟͈̱͊ͯ̾̾̾ͮM 6;ͮ̏ͬ́̚̚͞ͅL̨̲̬͉͍̳̪̣̦͔̘̺̜̲̐̎̽̇ͣ̚͘ 56; ̓͌̈̉̂̀̓̅̌̿͂̅ͫ̏̈ͭ̂̚͠͏̡̨̮̤̯͚̞̝̬̫ ̠̻͚͉̪̭̝̯ͅS̷̡̡͓̠̗̪̗̥͔̩͈̥͖͓̠ͪͩ̃́͐ ;ͬͪ͋̂̈ͣ̐ͯͪ͞Ẹ̢̡̹̹͕̞̘̥̲̔̓̐̏ͥ̅̽̇ͮS 8;̒́̀ͮ͢͠E̸͕̮͙̫͖͙̤̤̺̺͍̤̼̲͐ͯͫ͋̒͂̅ͥ 81;̎͘I̱̮̳̗͇̞̟̤̦̪̝͙ͤ̊͑̽̊ͤ̔̀̊̋ͬͬ̈̈̽&# 770;̿̚͞N̸̸ͨ͂̌̏ͭͪͦ̄ͣͬ̈͐̒̐͋ͮ̾̿̚҉̹̥͓͍ ̙G͚͈͎̖͚̰̻̫̹̣̖̗̗̬̊͊̓ͦ͊̓̒̅̑̐̃ͮͯ̊ͭ ;͜͞ ̸̵̴͚̹̗̗̤̫͔͙̪͇͍͛̄͗͛̇̉̽ͣ̇̄̎̿̊̾̄͋ ̚D̷͔͔͔̭͎̺͓̞͉̙̝̬̩͕̰̟̦̖͙͂ͫͯͯ͘̕͠R̢W 2;ͥ͌̀͑̈̅̑̒ͣ̎͒͌ͬ͝͡҉̪̖̤̗̝̪̖̫̬͖͇̳̮ 63;E̾̌ͧ̎̕͏̭̰̟ͅĂ̽̉̾̎̏ͫͨ͌ͮͭͫ̄̏ͩ̀̓̀ͮ&# 847;̸̹̲̥̦̝̣̤̠̖͖̠̪͇̯͝͞D̡̹̼̮̝͚̼̞̜͎̳̣& #804;̓ͣͩ͆ͣͥ̐̂̚ͅ ̛̽ͥͧ̈ͯ͟͏̡̙̠̣̼G̷̡ͥͭ̅̈͋̎̂̽ͤ́̆̊͌̄͏ ;̣͍͇̪̜̭̲̗̭͙̥̜̠͓͈̫̯͔A̹̞̖̣̮̤͚̩̝̗̫Q 0;̲̖̬ͯ́ͯͧ̉̅́͝͝ͅZ̵̷̷̔̌͆̄̐̓͂ͭ̾͂͊ͧͪ 73;̌̑̃̅̚҉͓̲̪͚̯E̡̨̡̢̬̻̻͎̱̼̫̩̞̩͉̤̻͇& #804;̰͈͋ͧ̀̾̄̒̂͂ͭ͐͠
 
Posted by Ecthalion (Member # 8825) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Samprimary:
IA IA I̺̳͙̲̜̩̩̝̜̱̞̠̹̣̘͖͗̍͑͆̌̐̕ͅÄ̶̧͕͚̻U 2;̤͇̣ͣͬ͆̽ͯ̑ͥ͐͋̎͆̉ͭͥ̋͆̀̀ ̙͓̞̪̫̪̥̰̟̲͖̌̂ͩͯͦ̿̎̓̎̊̊ͣ̃̐̚͢͞Ị̶ ;̬̝̺̫͖̻̠̼̥ͩ̋̓͛̋͂ͩ̃́̏̀ͅẮ͐̄̐͒̓͋ͥV 9;̑͊͟҉̻̟̞̗̦̙͓͕̗̘̗̤͢ͅ ̸͈̲̼̙̹͇̗͎͉̻̱̰͔̥̏ͭ̄͌ͬ̿͒ͪ̓̈́̓͜͟C̸ ;ͨ́͊̄͑̄̊҉̛̘̫̟̝̤͚̱͖̝͈̦̗̮͎͔̱̦͇̀T̸ 01;̟̣̱̰ͭ̓̔͌̄ͥ͛̅͐̈́̏̿͢͡͠H̸̛̱̞̳̬̜̹̗&# 854;͎͙̮̤̞̮̞̳̟̪̘ͮͬ̽̈́ͮͯͧ̓͛̒̐̽ͧ̈̿́͌&# 780;Ủ͔̝̺͔͖͇͉̱̦̱͎̱̠͍̱̯͚̖͙̽̏̔̆̂͐̓ͨͫ& #781;̃͋̚͠͠L̸̺̼̠̣͂̂̓ͨ͗ͤ͋̅ͨͩ̎ͯ̀U̠͇̺͚͕̻ ;͍̫̠͉̪̟͈̥̗̻̫̓̀ͮͤ̎̇̎̉ͩ͗ͨͨ̎̎́͢ͅͅ ̡̡̒̍̏̓̋̎̍̿ͦ̌͗̐͐̈̚͏̮͈̩̦͇̞̟͉͍̮̠͍ ̲̳͓̝̪ͅF̶̲̼͇͉̱̙͕ͥ̊̃̄͂͑ͥ͛̚͢͝T̷͕̼͚U 2;̯̟̭͓̞̬̦̘̦̪̥̰̟̼̓̍ͩ̐́̂̆ͭ͑ͨͩ͑͆̃́U 6;͜H̵̝̪̘͎̜̠̩̱͓͇̮̠̑͗ͣ̏̍ͨ͛̈́ͮ̀̚͢Ả͓&# 826;͉̗͔̮̱̦ͣ̔́̚̚͜G̸̢̖̜̳͕̹̝̞̟͇̗̞̪̩̟͈& #790;̙ͦ̌ͩ̍̎̔ͭͫ̏̒̍̄́ͅ'̵̧̡̲̳̺͔̲̞̻͎̱̱̟ ͖͓̞̦̮̻͚̊͐ͦ̓̓̑ͥ͡N̵̢̤͖̲̮͈̜̝̥̣ͫ̈́͒ ;̐ͦ͗́͊͆́̎̉̈́́͢͟ ̧̯̳̺̻̾͊ͥ̈́ͦ̐͑̈́́͠A̴̛͙̫͖̭̳̞̦̬͉̙̲ ;͖̣̤̳͊̓̂̉̀̕L̫̩͖̗̹̝̤͎̭̥̟͈̱͊ͯ̾̾̾ͮM 6;ͮ̏ͬ́̚̚͞ͅL̨̲̬͉͍̳̪̣̦͔̘̺̜̲̐̎̽̇ͣ̚͘ 56; ̓͌̈̉̂̀̓̅̌̿͂̅ͫ̏̈ͭ̂̚͠͏̡̨̮̤̯͚̞̝̬̫ ̠̻͚͉̪̭̝̯ͅS̷̡̡͓̠̗̪̗̥͔̩͈̥͖͓̠ͪͩ̃́͐ ;ͬͪ͋̂̈ͣ̐ͯͪ͞Ẹ̢̡̹̹͕̞̘̥̲̔̓̐̏ͥ̅̽̇ͮS 8;̒́̀ͮ͢͠E̸͕̮͙̫͖͙̤̤̺̺͍̤̼̲͐ͯͫ͋̒͂̅ͥ 81;̎͘I̱̮̳̗͇̞̟̤̦̪̝͙ͤ̊͑̽̊ͤ̔̀̊̋ͬͬ̈̈̽&# 770;̿̚͞N̸̸ͨ͂̌̏ͭͪͦ̄ͣͬ̈͐̒̐͋ͮ̾̿̚҉̹̥͓͍ ̙G͚͈͎̖͚̰̻̫̹̣̖̗̗̬̊͊̓ͦ͊̓̒̅̑̐̃ͮͯ̊ͭ ;͜͞ ̸̵̴͚̹̗̗̤̫͔͙̪͇͍͛̄͗͛̇̉̽ͣ̇̄̎̿̊̾̄͋ ̚D̷͔͔͔̭͎̺͓̞͉̙̝̬̩͕̰̟̦̖͙͂ͫͯͯ͘̕͠R̢W 2;ͥ͌̀͑̈̅̑̒ͣ̎͒͌ͬ͝͡҉̪̖̤̗̝̪̖̫̬͖͇̳̮ 63;E̾̌ͧ̎̕͏̭̰̟ͅĂ̽̉̾̎̏ͫͨ͌ͮͭͫ̄̏ͩ̀̓̀ͮ&# 847;̸̹̲̥̦̝̣̤̠̖͖̠̪͇̯͝͞D̡̹̼̮̝͚̼̞̜͎̳̣& #804;̓ͣͩ͆ͣͥ̐̂̚ͅ ̛̽ͥͧ̈ͯ͟͏̡̙̠̣̼G̷̡ͥͭ̅̈͋̎̂̽ͤ́̆̊͌̄͏ ;̣͍͇̪̜̭̲̗̭͙̥̜̠͓͈̫̯͔A̹̞̖̣̮̤͚̩̝̗̫Q 0;̲̖̬ͯ́ͯͧ̉̅́͝͝ͅZ̵̷̷̔̌͆̄̐̓͂ͭ̾͂͊ͧͪ 73;̌̑̃̅̚҉͓̲̪͚̯E̡̨̡̢̬̻̻͎̱̼̫̩̞̩͉̤̻͇& #804;̰͈͋ͧ̀̾̄̒̂͂ͭ͐͠

you write like the matrix?
 
Posted by Wingracer (Member # 12293) on :
 
It tells me Anne Rice. Not sure why, maybe because the character's name is Anna, haha.

One problem, I have never read an Anne Rice novel. Now I want to just to see if I do write like her but I'm vampired out.
 
Posted by MightyCow (Member # 9253) on :
 
Turns out that is a viral marketing campaign for a self publishing company. [Frown]
 
Posted by rivka (Member # 4859) on :
 
I apparently write like:
David Foster Wallace
Kurt Vonnegut (got this result twice, on completely unrelated samples)
Cory Doctorow
Ursula K. Le Guin
 
Posted by Godric (Member # 4587) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Nighthawk:
I write like Cory Doctorow.

Apparently I do as well. At least it wasn't Stephenie Meyer.
 
Posted by fugu13 (Member # 2859) on :
 
Sadly, I suspect they use a very simple approach to discern this. A nuanced approach could be quite interesting.
 
Posted by August (Member # 12307) on :
 
Dan Brown twice, H.P. Lovecraft once. Weird combo.
 
Posted by PSI Teleport (Member # 5545) on :
 
Baron, according to this article, Margaret Atwood got Stephen King when she tried it.
 
Posted by Mucus (Member # 9735) on :
 
Looks like a lame algorithm.

Oddly enough, I'm the only one here that seems to have gotten Arthur C. Clark though (yay biology?).
 
Posted by rollainm (Member # 8318) on :
 
"I'm a little teapot" got me James Joyce. And apparently so did "Stephen King" copied several times.
 
Posted by Orincoro (Member # 8854) on :
 
Has anyone tried writing samples of the famous authors themselves?
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
It's the same algorithm (or something similar) as what gmail-type-things use to create spam filters. There was an interview about it, I'll dig it up if anyone cares.
 
Posted by sinflower (Member # 12228) on :
 
Every single text I entered got me a different author, except for when I fed it different pieces of the same paper. It seems like this site only analyzes diction and nothing else...
 
Posted by Raymond Arnold (Member # 11712) on :
 
Doesn't diction refer to actually "speaking?"
 
Posted by Baron Samedi (Member # 9175) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by PSI Teleport:
Baron, according to this article, Margaret Atwood got Stephen King when she tried it.

[ROFL] That is classic.
 
Posted by fugu13 (Member # 2859) on :
 
Presumably they're using naive bayes with the term frequencies (possibly including n-grams).
 
Posted by Orincoro (Member # 8854) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Raymond Arnold:
Doesn't diction refer to actually "speaking?"

Not exclusively. In this case, it refers to word choice and use in writing.
 
Posted by BlackBlade (Member # 8376) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Godric:
quote:
Originally posted by Nighthawk:
I write like Cory Doctorow.

Apparently I do as well. At least it wasn't Stephenie Meyer.
Don't worry about it, I typed a bunch of excerpts from Ender's Game into the reader, and it came out as Cory Doctorow. I guess we should all migrate over to Mr. Doctorow's forum if Mr. Card ever kicks the bucket.

edit: I also typed, "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy" over and over but I got P. G. Wodehouse not Steven King.

second edit: Apparently I'm not the first to try the latter experiment.

[ July 21, 2010, 04:22 AM: Message edited by: BlackBlade ]
 
Posted by Mr. Y (Member # 11590) on :
 
Based on only one sample (one of my recent posts) I apparently write like P.G. Wodehouse.

Another sample, which consisted of several short posts (all from the same thread) informed me that I write like Stephen King.

To get some level of certainty in the outcome I checked the above sentences as well; P.G. Wodehouse again... Perhaps I should try to read some of his work. [Smile]

And checking an e-mail message I just wrote for work I got the following outcome: Stephenie Meyer. [Confused]

[ July 21, 2010, 06:02 AM: Message edited by: Mr. Y ]
 
Posted by PSI Teleport (Member # 5545) on :
 
quote:
I also typed, "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy" over and over but I got P. G. Wodehouse not Steven King.
Maybe that just means Wodehouse is repetitive.
 
Posted by Phanto (Member # 5897) on :
 
quote:

I thought I'd try for Steven King, so I entered the following text:

quote:blood guts artery spurt blood murder kill death tear out disembowel dismember cut into pieces slash with a knife and spray with blood.

It gave me Margaret Atwood. So much for that.

LOL! I put in a review article I wrote on Acai berry and got Margaret Atwood as well. I guess the two aren't that disimilar! =)
 
Posted by kmbboots (Member # 8576) on :
 
H.P. Lovecraft and Oscar Wilde.
 
Posted by Godric (Member # 4587) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Mr. Y:

And checking an e-mail message I just wrote for work I got the following outcome: Stephenie Meyer. [Confused]

[Laugh]
 
Posted by Herblay (Member # 11834) on :
 
An article I wrote for the company newsletter came out as William Shakespeare. Passages from the YA novel I'm working were rated as Stephen King.
 
Posted by Flaming Toad on a Stick (Member # 9302) on :
 
Forum post looked like Cory Doctorow.

Random keyboard mashing looked like David Foster Wallace.

Huh.
 
Posted by Lisa (Member # 8384) on :
 
http://lamrot-hakol.blogspot.com/2010/07/who-do-i-write-like.html
 
Posted by T:man (Member # 11614) on :
 
Mario Puzo?
 
Posted by Lisa (Member # 8384) on :
 
Right?
 
Posted by Shan (Member # 4550) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Baron Samedi:
I put a few of Sarah Palin's tweets in there, and it says she writes like William Shakespeare. So I guess we all owe someone an apology. [Big Grin]

(Actually, I copied and pasted Moroni Chapter 10, and it came back as Shakespeare. But it's surely all the "cometh" and "denieth" and such.)

Dang!!! And here I was feeling proud of getting Shakespeare. *sigh* Can't win for losing.
 
Posted by Lyrhawn (Member # 7039) on :
 
I posted a few paragraphs without dialogue from a story I've been working on and got Stephen King. Then from the same story, used only dialogue and got James Joyce.

Then I used a journal entry from two months ago and got Edgar Allen Poe.
 


Copyright © 2008 Hatrack River Enterprises Inc. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2